U.S. Customs and Border Protection · CROSS Database
Ruling Request; U.S. International Trade Commission; Limited Exclusion Order; Investigation No. 337-TA-1370; Certain Power Converter Modules and Computing Systems Containing the Same
H348257 July 8, 2025 OT:RR:BSTC:EOE H348257 WMW CATEGORY: 19 U.S.C. § 1337; Unfair Competition Mr. Paul Brinkman Kirkland & Ellis LLP 1301 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W. Washington, DC 20004 Mr. Daniel Valencia DLA Piper LLP (US) 500 Eighth Street, NW Washington, DC 20004 VIA EMAIL: paul.brinkman@kirkland.com, daniel.valencia@us.dlapiper.com, RE: Ruling Request; U.S. International Trade Commission; Limited Exclusion Order; Investigation No. 337-TA-1370; Certain Power Converter Modules and Computing Systems Containing the Same Dear Mr. Brinkman and Mr. Valencia: Pursuant to 19 C.F.R. Part 177, the Exclusion Order Enforcement Branch (“EOE Branch”), Regulations and Rulings, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (“CBP”) issues this administrative ruling in response to the separately filed requests from Quanta Computer Inc. and Quanta Computer USA, Inc. (collectively, “Quanta”) and NVIDIA Corporation (“NVIDIA”), both of which are dated May 16, 2025. The ruling requests were submitted after initial conference calls and preliminary submissions from Quanta, NVIDIA and Vicor Corporation (“Vicor”), as further detailed below. The question presented in these ruling requests is whether the articles at issue, as described in this ruling, are subject to the limited exclusion order (“LEO”) that the U.S. International Trade Commission (“Commission” or “ITC”) issued in Investigation No. 337-TA- 1370 (“the underlying investigation” or “the 1370 investigation”), based on its finding a violation of Section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930, as amended, 19 U.S.C. § 1337 (“Section 337”). The LEO from the 1370 investigation bars the unlicensed entry for consumption into the United States of power convert modules and computing systems containing the same, as defined in ¶ 2 of the LEO, that infringe claim 1 of U.S. Patent No. 9,166,481 (“the ’481 patent”) or claims 1-7 of U.S. Patent No. 9,516,761 (“the ‘761 patent”) (collectively, “the asserted patents”) and that are manufactured or imported by or on behalf of (i) Delta Electronics, Inc., Delta Electronics (Americas) Ltd., and DET Logistics (USA) Corporation; (ii) Cyntec Co., Ltd.; (iii) Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. Ltd. (d/b/a, Foxconn Technology Group), Foxconn Industrial Internet Co. Ltd., and FII USA Inc. (a/k/a Foxconn Industrial, Internet USA Inc.); (iv) Ingrasys Technology Inc. and Ingrasys Technology USA Inc.; and (v) Quanta. See Certain Power Converter Modules and Computing Systems Containing the Same, Investigation No. 337-TA-1370, EDIS Doc. ID 843485, Limited Exclusion Order (February 13, 2025). As noted above, this ruling is based on two separately filed requests pursuant to 19 C.F.R. Part 177, which the EOE Branch has adjudicated on an inter partes basis. The proceeding involved the three parties with a direct and demonstrable interest in the question presented by the ruling requests: (1) Quanta, a ruling requester and respondent in the underlying investigation at the Commission; (2) NVIDIA, a ruling requester and non-respondent third party that did not participate in the underlying investigation; and (3) Vicor, the other interested party and complainant from the underlying investigation as the owner of the asserted patents. See 19 C.F.R. § 177.1(c). Furthermore, we note that determinations of the Commission resulting from the underlying investigation or a related proceeding under 19 C.F.R. Part 210 are binding authority on CBP and, in the case of conflict, will modify or revoke by operation of law any contrary CBP ruling or decision pertaining to Section 337 exclusion orders. Finally, the parties have been asked to identify confidential information, including information subject to the administrative protective order in the underlying investigation, with [[red brackets]] in their submissions. See 19 C.F.R. §§ 177.2, 177.8. If there is information in this administrative ruling not currently bracketed in red [[ ]] that either party believes constitutes confidential information, and should be redacted from the published ruling, the parties are to contact CBP within ten (10) working days of the date of this ruling to indicate the same. See, e.g., 19 C.F.R. § 177.8(a)(3). I. BACKGROUND A. ITC Investigation No. 337-TA-1370 The Commission instituted Investigation No. 337-TA-1370 based on a complaint filed by Vicor. Certain Power Converter Modules and Computing Systems Containing the Same, Inv. No. 337-TA-1370, EDIS Doc. ID 844518, Commission Opinion (Feb. 27, 2025) (“Comm’n Op.”) at 2. The complaint, as supplemented, alleged a violation of Section 337 by reason of infringement of certain claims of the ‘481 patent, the ‘761 patent, and the ‘950 patent. Id. The notice of investigation named as respondents Delta Electronics, Inc. of Taipei, Taiwan, Delta Electronics (Americas) Ltd. of Fremont, California, and Delta Electronics (USA) Inc. of Plano, Texas; Cyntec Co., Ltd. of Hsinchu, Taiwan; Quanta Computer Inc. of Taoyuan City, Taiwan, Quanta Cloud Technology Inc. of Taoyuan City, Taiwan, Quanta Cloud Technology USA LLC of San Jose, California, and Quanta Computer USA, Inc. of Fremont, California; Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. Ltd. (d/b/a Foxconn Technology Group) of Taipei City, Taiwan, Foxconn Industrial Internet Co. Ltd. of Shenzhen, China, FII USA Inc. (a/k/a Foxconn Industrial Internet USA Inc.) of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, Ingrasys Technology Inc. of Taoyuan City, Taiwan, and Ingrasys Technology USA Inc. of San Jose, California. Id. The Commission’s Office of Unfair Import Investigations (“OUII”) was named as a party in the investigation. Id. 2 On September 27, 2024, the Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”) issued a final initial determination (“FID”) finding a violation of Section 337. Id. at 3. Specifically, the ALJ determined that a violation of Section 337 occurred in the importation into the United States, the sale for importation, or the sale within the United States after importation, of the accused products that infringed the ‘481 and ‘761 patents, but not as to the ‘950 patent. Id. On December 4, 2024, the Commission issued a notice in which it determined to review the FID in part and requested submissions responding to the Commission’s issues under review and on remedy, the public interest, and bonding. Id. at 5. In the limited exclusion order, the Commission ordered that “[p]ower converter modules and computing systems containing the same that infringe one or more of claim 1 of the ’481 patent and claims 1-7 of the ’761 patent and are manufactured abroad by, or on behalf of, or imported by or on behalf of Respondents or any of their affiliated companies, parents, subsidiaries, agents, or other related business entities, or their successors or assigns, are excluded from entry for consumption into the United States, entry for consumption from a foreign-trade zone, or withdrawal from a warehouse for consumption, for the remaining terms of the Asserted Patents, except under license from, or with the permission of, the patent owner or as provided by law.” Certain Power Converter Modules and Computing Systems Containing the Same, Inv. No. 337- TA-1370, EDIS Doc. ID 843485, Limited Exclusion Order (February 13, 2025) at 2. The Commission defined the articles covered by the limited exclusion order as “power converter modules used in data center server, artificial intelligence and cloud computing systems, to power artificial intelligence (‘AI’) accelerators, tensor processing units (‘TPU’), graphical processing units (‘GPU’) and central processing units (‘CPU’), and computing systems containing the same. Id. at 3. B. Articles At Issue According to NVIDIA, the “NVIDIA products that are the subject of this request include, at least, the products listed below (‘NVIDIA Blackwell Products’): o ‘Blackwell’ is the name of the architecture of a Graphics Processing Unit (‘GPU’). NVIDIA Blackwell GPUs may be included on ‘mezzanine’ boards marketed as ‘SXM6’ or [[ ]] boards. Unlike the products accused in the 1370 Investigation, the GPU mezzanine boards do not use power converter modules. Instead, power conversion is performed by circuitry distributed on the GPU mezzanine board. The GPU mezzanine board does not have a power converter module at all, let alone one from Delta or Cyntec. o The GPU mezzanine boards are designed to be plugged into baseboards. For example, a Blackwell baseboard includes eight (8) GPU mezzanine boards. The baseboards likewise do not contain any power converter modules, let alone any made by Delta or Cyntec. o NVIDIA also designs server boards with Grace CPUs and Blackwell GPUs that work with a [[ ]] Power Delivery Board. As with the other NVIDIA Blackwell Products put at 3 issue by Vicor, these Power Delivery Boards do not contain power converter modules, let alone any made by Delta or Cyntec.” NVIDIA Ruling Request at 2. Additionally, these “Nvidia Blackwell Products [are] manufactured and/or imported by Quanta.” Quanta Ruling Request at 1. While the parties dispute several points in this inter partes proceeding, there appears to be no dispute that the NVIDIA Blackwell Products at issue in this ruling request do not contain power converter modules manufactured by or on behalf of Delta or Cyntec. See NVIDIA Ruling Request at 6 (“The NVIDIA Blackwell Products do not use the infringing Delta or Cyntec power converter modules.”); Quanta Ruling Request at 6 (“Vicor does not define what it means by Nvidia’s ‘new Blackwell computing systems,’ but Nvidia presumes from context that Vicor refers to its SXM6 mezzanine boards and B200 server boards (‘Nvidia Blackwell Products’), neither of which contain Delta or Cyntec power converter modules.”); Vicor Response at 2 (“[T]he LEO in the 1370 Investigation is not limited to Quanta’s (and Foxconn’s) computing systems that contain only the adjudicated Delta and Cyntec modules.”). II. PRELIMINARY SUBMISSIONS Before establishing this inter partes proceeding, the EOE Branch held an initial round of conference calls with Vicor, Quanta, and NVIDIA based on their joint request. These preliminary conference calls allowed each side to discuss certain issues, provide the relevant factual background, and identify differing views regarding the proper administration of the LEO. For instance, on April 3, 2025, the EOE Branch held a conference call and, at its conclusion, requested that Vicor provide its views in writing by the following day. Vicor submitted a letter to the EOE Branch on April 4, 2025, in which Vicor disputed NVIDIA’s argument that the articles at issue “do not fall within the scope of the limited exclusion order in the 1370 Investigation because [Nvidia Blackwell Products] replace Respondent Delta’s power converter modules with power converters the ITC did not have an opportunity to adjudicate in the 1370 Investigation.” Victor Preliminary Submission at 1. In Vicor’s view, “Nvidia’s view is erroneous under Commission and Federal Circuit precedent.” Id. On April 9, 2025, Quanta submitted a letter to the EOE Branch in response to Vicor. Quanta argued “that Vicor, the ALJ and the Commission consistently and repeatedly limited the scope of the 1370 investigation and the products subject to exclusion to Delta and Cyntec power converter modules ‘Accused Products’) and computing systems containing the same (‘Accused Systems’)—not computing systems containing other manufacturers’ power converter modules.” Quanta Preliminary Response at 4. NVIDIA also submitted a letter to the EOE Branch on April 9, 2025, stating its view that “Vicor mistakenly argues that NVIDIA’s ‘new Blackwell computing systems are within the scope of the LEO in the 1370 Investigation and these unlicensed computing systems are barred from entry into the United States by Respondents.’ Vicor bases its argument solely on the opinions in Certain Graphics Sys., Components Thereof, and Digital Televisions Containing the Same, Inv. No. 337-TA-1318 (‘Graphics Systems’). But those opinions recognize that the scope of an LEO is limited to ‘all products of named respondents within the scope of the investigation that are covered by the patent claims as to which a violation has been found.’ Graphics Systems, Comm’n 4 Op. on Pet. for Recon. at 17-18; see also Kyocera Wireless Corp. v. Int’l Trade Comm’n, 545 F.3d 1340, 1358 (Fed. Cir. 2008) (‘Section 337 permits exclusion of the imports of non-respondents only via a general exclusion order’).” NVIDIA Preliminary Response at 1. On April 14, 2025, Vicor submitted another letter to the EOE Branch responding to arguments Quanta and NVIDIA raised in their respective letters from April 9, 2025. In particular, Vicor stated that, as with the parties in Graphics Systems, Quanta is a named respondent manufacturing the Blackwell computing systems, which places them within scope of the LEO. Vicor Letter to EOE Branch, dated April 14, 2025, at 2. On April 15, 2025, NVIDIA submitted a letter to the EOE Branch to address certain points, highlighting its view that Vicor “does not dispute that the Commission’s determination in Certain Graphics Sys., Components Thereof, and Digital Televisions Containing the Same, Inv. No. 337-TA-1318 (“Graphics Systems”) is distinguishable from and did not overrule the Commission’s Advisory Opinion in Certain GPS Devices and Products Containing Same, Inv. No. 337-TA-602 (“GPS Devices”). NVIDIA Letter to EOE Branch, dated April 15, 2025, at 1. On April 17, 2025, the EOE Branch held another conference call with Vicor, Quanta, and NVIDIA to discuss various procedural issues arising from the submissions to that point. Following the conference call, the EOE Branch sent an email to the parties reiterating the issues raised during the conference call and made the following request: As discussed, the EOE Branch requests the views of the parties on the following three procedural questions. As a reminder, the parties should not discuss or present any arguments on the merits question regarding admissibility of the articles at issue. (1) Should the EOE Branch or the ITC address admissibility of the articles at issue and, if the latter, what should CBP do in the interim with respect to any importation of the articles at issue? (2) If the EOE Branch addresses admissibility of the articles at issue, which party should request the ruling and initiate the inter partes proceeding under 19 CFR 177? (3) If the EOE Branch addresses admissibility of the articles at issue, what should be the procedural schedule for the inter partes proceeding, taking into account the different grounds or legal theories related to admissibility that have been discussed in the submissions to this point or mentioned during the conference call? EOE Branch Email to Parties, dated April 17, 2025. On April 21, 2025, Vicor submitted a response to the EOE Branch. In Vicor’s view, either the EOE Branch or the ITC could address the admissibility of the articles at issue and that either Quanta or NVIDIA should be the party that submits a ruling request to initiate an inter partes proceeding under 19 C.F.R. Part 177. Vicor Procedural Submission at 1-3. Vicor also proposed a procedural schedule. Id. at 4. On the same day, NVIDIA submitted a response to the EOE Branch, stating that either the ITC or the EOE Branch could reach the admissibility determination and requested expedited treatment for any inter partes proceeding under 19 C.F.R. Part 177. 5 NVIDIA Procedural Submission at 2. Furthermore, NVIDIA stated that Vicor should be the party that submits the ruling request under Part 177. Id. NVIDIA likewise provided a procedural schedule. Id. at 3. Finally, Quanta submitted a response to the EOE Branch, indicating that “[i]t would be preferable to downstream Respondents for the Commission to clarify that the LEO does not apply to downstream Respondents’ computing systems that do not contain any Respondents’ power converter modules, particularly if done in a way that would be directly appealable to the Federal Circuit (i.e. in a modification proceeding).” Quanta Procedural Submission at 1. As such, the “downstream Respondents suggest[ed] that the parties submit this issue to the ITC for determination only if CBP agrees not to exclude this category of products in the interim. If CBP determines otherwise, downstream Respondents request that the EOE Branch decide the legal issue through a formal 177 ruling on an expedited basis.” Id. (emphasis in original). As with the other parties, Quanta provided a procedural schedule for any inter partes proceeding. Id. at 2. Taking the parties’ procedural submissions into consideration, the EOE Branch responded by email on May 12, 2025, with the following: Dear Counsel, The Exclusion Order Enforcement (“EOE”) Branch has reviewed the procedural submissions (filed on April 21, 2025) from (1) Vicor Corporation (“Vicor”), the complainant and patent owner in Investigation No. 337-TA-1370 (“the underlying investigation”) at the U.S. International Trade Commission (“Commission” or “ITC”); (2) Quanta Computer Inc. and Quanta Computer USA, Inc. (“Quanta”) and, to the extent relevant to the import transactions at issue, Foxconn Industrial Internet Co. Ltd. (“Foxconn”), the respondents in the underlying investigation that manufacture downstream products; and (3) NVIDIA Corporation (“NVIDIA”), who was not a party in the underlying investigation but whose Blackwell computing systems (also referred to as the Blackwell boards) (“articles at issue”) are at the center of this dispute. Based on its review of the procedural submissions, and taking into consideration the other submissions from the parties and companies above filed before the procedural submissions, the EOE Branch provides the following in response. *** A party seeking to import articles potentially subject to an exclusion order issued by the Commission under Section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930, as amended, 19 U.S.C. § 1337 (“Section 337”), has the burden to establish noninfringement, or that the articles are otherwise outside the exclusion order’s scope, as a condition of entry. See Hyundai Elecs. Indus. Co. v. Int’l Trade Comm’n, 899 F.2d 1204, 1210 (Fed. Cir. 1990); see also Certain Road Construction Machines and Components Thereof, Inv. No. 337-TA-1088 (Modification), Commission Opinion, Doc. ID 719534 (Sept. 14, 2020) at 12-13 (“Consistent with the Commission’s long- standing practice, the scope of the [exclusion order] at issue here includes all [ ] infringing road construction machines and components thereof, whether they have been adjudicated in the investigation or were later introduced.”) (emphasis 6 added). When an importer fails to carry this burden to establish admissibility, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (“CBP”) will, as directed by the Commission, exclude the articles from entry for consumption. With respect to unadjudicated articles in the Section 337 context, the Commission has confirmed the availability of proceedings for parties to carry the burden described above and ob