Base
2301192004-08-04Headquarters

Protest 2002-03-100568; substitution unused merchandise drawback; cottonseed oil; commercial interchangeability; 19 U.S.C. 1313(j)(2).

U.S. Customs and Border Protection · CROSS Database · 1 HTS code referenced

Summary

Protest 2002-03-100568; substitution unused merchandise drawback; cottonseed oil; commercial interchangeability; 19 U.S.C. 1313(j)(2).

Ruling Text

HQ 230119 August 4, 2004 DRA-4; RR:CR:DR HQ 230119 MK CATEGORY: Drawback Port Director Customs and Border Protection 423 Canal Street New Orleans, LA 70130-2341 Attn: Drawback Branch Re: Protest 2002-03-100568; substitution unused merchandise drawback; cottonseed oil; commercial interchangeability; 19 U.S.C. 1313(j)(2). Dear Sir: The above-referenced protest on behalf of Archer Daniels Midland Company (“ADM”) was forwarded to this office for further review. Our decision follows. FACTS: According to the Customs Form (“CF”) 19, dated July 23, 2003, this protest covers four drawback entries (or claims) filed on February 4, 2002: JK5-xxxxxx7-5; JK5-xxxxxx8-3; JK5-xxxxx12-5; and JK5-xxxxx14-1. The drawback claims were liquidated without drawback on April 25, 2003. Claim JK5-xxxxxx7-5 Import Documents The Drawback Entry Form, CF 7551, claims drawback under 19 U.S.C. 1313(j)(2) of 499,867 kg of “Semi refined cottonseed oil,” classified under subheading 1512.29, Harmonized Tariff Schedule United States (“HTSUS”), with a value of about $.6 per kg. The oil had an import date of October 15, 1998. The file contains an Entry Summary, CF 7501, for entry number xxx3309-5 with a handwritten note stating “Drawback entry JK5-xxxxxx7-5.” This document states the entry date is October 16, 1998, the importing carrier is the Stolt Tenacity, and a total of 17,950,000 kg of merchandise was entered, from Argentina, at a total value of $1,2xx,xxx. This form lists nine separate invoices of merchandise. The merchandise on each invoice is “Semi refined Cotton seed oil” classified under subheading 1512.29.0020, HTSUS. The Protestant also provided a telex, dated August 4, 1998, from an address at ADM_TELEX, confirming the sale of 5950 metric tons of Argentine semi-refined cottonseed oil at about $600 per metric ton and per ANEC 111 quality. The Certificate of Analysis, on Thionville Laboratories, Inc. letterhead, dated October 16, 1998, represents 26,139,934 pounds of Argentine Cottonseed oil onboard the Stolt Tenacity. The sample was taken in accordance with AOCS Official Method C 1-47 and found: Flash Point Above 250°F Bleached Color 35 Yellow; 3.5 Red Free Fatty Acids, as Olic 0.21% Moisture and Volatile Matter 09% Insoluble Impurities .02% Export Documents The CF 7551 states that 499,867 metric tons of “Semi refined cottonseed oil,” classified under subheading 1512.29, HTSUS, was exported on May 9, 2001 to El Salvador. The Notice of Intent to Export, Destroy, or Return Merchandise for Purposes of Drawback, CF 7553, for this entry states that on May 8, 2001, 500 metric tons of semi-refined cottonseed oil, under subheading 1512.29.0020, HTSUS, was intended to be exported from the Port of Houston, Texas, on the Victor Dubrovskiy, to El Salvador. The merchandise specifications are: FFA Max 0.25% M&I Max .25% Color when bleached may not exceed AOCS 2.7 The export value is about $196,xxx. The file also contains a contract, unsigned by ADM International Oils Department, number 51153 B, on Pasternak, Baum & Co., Inc. letterhead, dated May 1, 2001, for 500 metric tons of “USA Prime Beachable Summer Yellow Cottonseed Oil (PBSY) in accordance with Rules 162 and E-6 of the National Cotton-Seed Products Association rules.” The seller is ADM International Oils Department of Decatur, Illinois, and the buyer is Pasternak, Baum & Co., Inc. of Greenwich, Connecticut. The price is about $400.00 per metric ton, and the shipment date is May 25, 2001. The file contains an invoice on ADM letterhead, dated May 10, 2001, to Pasternak Baum & CO of Greenwich, Connecticut. This invoice states that 499,867 metric tons of semi refined cottonseed oil, at about $400.00 per metric ton, was brought from the port of Houston, Texas to Acajutla, El Salvador on the Victor Dubrovskiy. The total value of the merchandise is $196,xxx. The Bill of Lading, dated May 9, 2001, for the M.T. Victor Dubrovshkiy, states that 499,867 metric tons of “aceite de algodon (PBSY)” were transported from the Port of Houston, Texas to Acajutla, El Salvador. The second Certificate of Analysis on Thionville Laboratories, Inc. letterhead, dated May 9, 2001, represents 1,102,006 pounds or 499,867 metric tons Aciete de algodon (PBSY) on board the Victor Dubrovshiy. The sample taken was in accordance with AOCS Official Method C 1-47. It found: The oil is reasonably free from visible foreign material. The oil is clear at temperatures sufficiently high to melt the stearine. Flavor and Odor Sweet Bleached Color 13 Yellow; 1.3 Red Free Fatty Acids, as Oleic 0.02% Moisture and Volatile Matter 0.010% This oil meets specification basis rule 162 and E-6 basis ship’s tanks sample. Claim JK5-xxxxxx8-3 Import Documents The Drawback Entry Form, CF 7551, claims drawback under 19 U.S.C. 1313(j)(2) on 999,947 kg of “Semi refined cottonseed oil,” classified under subheading 1512.29, HTSUS, with a value of about $.6 per kg. The oil had an import date of October 15. The import documents described for the first claim, entry number 3309-5, also apply to this drawback claim. Export Documents The CF 7551 states that 999.947 metric tons of “Semi refined cottonseed oil,” classified under subheading 1512.29, HTSUS, was exported on May 10, 2001, to El Salvador. The Notice of Intent to Export, Destroy, or Return Merchandise for Purposes of Drawback, CF 7553, for this entry states that on May 10, 2001, 1000 metric tons of semi-refined cottonseed oil, under subheading 1512.29.0020, HTSUS, was intended to be exported from the Port of Houston, Texas, on the Victor Dubrovskiy, to El Salvador. The merchandise specifications are: FFA Max 0.25% M&I Max .25% Color when bleached may not exceed AOCS 2.7 The export value is about $400,000. The file also contains contract, unsigned by ADM International Oils Department, number 51164 B, on Pasternak, Baum & Co., Inc. letterhead, dated May 7, 2001, for 1,000 metric tons of “PBSY COTTONSEED OIL- specifications as per rules E6 and 162 of the NCPA.” The seller is ADM International Oils Department of Decatur, Illinois, and the buyer is Pasternak, Baum & Co., Inc. of Greenwich, Connecticut. The price is about “$400.00 per metric ton net weight, in bulk, CANDF Acajutla, El Salvador, and the shipment date is “May 5-20, 2001 – buyer’s call”. The file contains an invoice on ADM letterhead, dated May 10, 2001, to Pasternak Baum & CO of Greenwich, Connecticut. This invoice covers 999,947 metric tons of PBSY cottonseed oil, at about $400.00 per metric ton, from the port of Houston, Texas to Acajutla, El Salvador on the Victor Dubrovskiy. The total value of the merchandise is about $400,000. The Bill of Lading, dated May 10, 2001, for the M.T. Victor Dubrovshkiy, states that 999,947 metric tons of “PBSY Cottonseed oil” were transported from the Port of Houston, Texas to Acajutla, El Salvador. The second Certificate of Analysis on Thionville Laboratories, Inc. letterhead, dated May 10, 2001, represents 2,204,483 pounds or 999,947 metric tons PBSY Cottonseed Oil on board the Victor Dubrovshiy. The sample taken was in accordance with AOCS Official Method C 1-47. It found: The oil is reasonably free from visible foreign material. The oil is clear at temperatures sufficiently high to melt the stearine. Flavor and Odor Sweet Bleached Color 11 Yellow; 1.1 Red Free Fatty Acids, as Oleic 0.02% Moisture and Volatile Matter 0.06% This oil meets specification basis rule 162 and E-6 basis ship’s tanks sample. Claim JK5-xxxxx12-5 Import Documents The Drawback Entry Form, CF 7551, states that 999,968 kg of “Semi refined cottonseed oil,” classified under subheading 1512.29, HTSUS, with a value of about $.6 per kg. The oil had an import date of October 15, 1998. The import documents described for the first claim, entry number 3309-5, also apply to this drawback claim. Export Documents The CF 7551 states that 999.968 kg of “Semi refined cottonseed oil,” classified under subheading 1512.29, HTSUS, was exported on September 29, 2001, to El Salvador. The Notice of Intent to Export, Destroy, or Return Merchandise for Purposes of Drawback, CF 7553, for this entry states that on September 26, 2001, 1000 metric tons of semi-refined cottonseed oil, under subheading 1512.29.0020, HTSUS, was intended to be exported from the Port of Houston, Texas, on the Panam Celeste, to El Salvador. The merchandise specifications are: FFA Max 0.25% M&I Max .25% Color when bleached may not exceed AOCS 2.7 The export value is about $400,000. The file also contains a sale confirmation, on ADM Oilseed Processing letterhead, signed by a representative of Archer Daniels Midland Co., contract number 1169, dated July 1, 2001, for 1,000 metric tons of “Semi refined cottonseed oil in bulk” within the specification of NCPA Rule E-6. The seller is Archer Daniels Midland Co. of Decatur, Illinois, and the buyer is ADM Latin America Inc. of Guatemala. The price exceeds $400 per metric ton. The purchase settlement, dated November 6, 2001, confirmed this information and states the final amount is about $400,000. The file contains an invoice on ADM letterhead, dated September 29, 2001, to ADM Latin America Inc. This invoice covers 999,968 metric tons of Semi refined cottonseed oil, in excess of $400 per metric ton, from the port of Houston, Texas to Acajutla, El Salvador on the Panam Celeste. The total value of the merchandise is about $400,000. The Bill of Lading, dated September 29, 2001, for the M.T. Panam Celeste, states that 999,968 metric tons of “semi refined cottonseed oil in bulk” were transported from the Port of Houston, Texas to Acajutla, El Salvador. The second Certificate of Analysis on Thionville Laboratories, Inc. letterhead, dated September 29, 2001, represents 2,204,529 pounds or 999,968 metric tons semi- refined cottonseed oil on board the Panam Celeste. The sample taken was in accordance with AOCS Official Method C 1-47. It found: The oil is reasonably free from visible foreign material. The oil is clear at temperatures sufficiently high to melt the stearine. Flavor and Odor Sweet Color 35 Yellow; 4.1 Red Free Fatty Acids, as Oleic 0.07% Moisture and Volatile Matter 0.10% Flash Point Above 250(F This oil is in accordance with rules 162 and E-6 of the NCPA current rules. The file also contains a purchase settlement, dated November 6, 2001, for 999.968 MT of US #2 O/B Cotton Oil credited to and ADM account, for oil shipped to El Salvador per the Panam Celeste. Claim JK5-xxxxx14-1 Import Documents This drawback claim consists of two entries. Both entries are for semi refined cottonseed oil, classified under HTSUS heading import 1512.29. The first entry, entry number xxxx309-5, has an entry date of October 15, 1998, and covers 357,034 kg at an entered value of about $.6 per kg. The import documents described for the first drawback claim, entry number 3309-5, also apply for this drawback claim. The second entry, entry number xxxx424-2, has an entry date of June 21, 1999, and covers 1,142,889 kg at an entered value in excess of $400 per kg. The file also contains an Entry Summary, CF 7501, for entry number xxxx424-2 with a handwritten note stating “Drawback entry JK5-xxxxx14-1.” This document states the entry date is June 19, 1999, the importing carrier is the Toyokaze, and a total of 5,000,000 kg of merchandise, described as “Semi refined Cotton seed oil in bulk” and classified under subheading 1512.29.0020, HTSUS, was entered, from Argentina, at a total value of about $300,000. The Protestant also provided a telex, dated February 26, 1999, from an address at corp.admworld.com, confirming the sale of 8,000 metric tons of Argentine semi-refined cottonseed oil in excess of $400 per kg. and per ANEC 111 quality. The Certificate of Analysis, on Thionville Laboratories, Inc. letterhead, dated June 24, 1999, represents 10,913,734 pounds from the Toyokaze. The sample was taken in accordance with AOCS Official Method C 1-47 and found: Flash Point Above 250°F Color 35 Yellow; 7.6 Red Free Fatty Acids, as Oleic 0.04% Moisture and Volatile Matter .12% There is also a second Certificate of Quality, dated May 27, 1999, from Thionville Do Brasil Ltda. of Sao Paulo, Brazil. It states the commodity is “Argentine Cottonseed Oil, In Bulk,” from San Lorenzo, Argentina on the Toyokaze destined to New Orleans, Louisiana. 2,000,000 kilos are loaded and the specifications are: Actual FFA Max .25 Pct 0.070 pct Moisture and Impurities Max .25 Pct .18 pct Colour (Lovibond 5.25 inch) 12 Red Max/ basis Yellow 35 Red 8.5/ Yellow 35 Oil with Flashpoint below 250 Deg F is rejectable Above 250(F Export Documents The CF 7551 states that 1,499,923 metric tons of “PSBY cottonseed oil,” classified under subheading 1512.29, HTSUS, was exported on September 28, 2001, to Korea. The Notice of Intent to Export, Destroy, or Return Merchandise for Purposes of Drawback, CF 7553, for this entry states that on September 27, 2001, 1,500 metric tons of semi-refined cottonseed oil, under subheading 1512.29.0020, HTSUS, was intended to be exported from the Port of Houston, Texas, on the Golden Tomo, to South Korea. The merchandise specifications are: FFA Max 0.25% M&I Max .20% Color when bleached may not exceed AOCS 2.7 The export value is about $600,000. The file also contains an internal email message, dated September 25, 2001, both from and to addresses at “@corp.admworld.com” describing a sales contract. The message included the following information: Seller: Archer Daniels Midland Co. Buyer: Doobo Co., Ltd of Korea Quantity: 1.500 Metric Tons of PBSY Cottonseed oil Commodity: PBSY Cottonseed oil as per NCPA Rule E-6 Bleached colour basis 2.5 max 2.7 F.F.A. 0.25 pct M and V Basis 0.10 pct max 0.10 pct Price: US dollars 4xx.- cost and frieght Pyongtaek (South Korea) The file contains an invoice on ADM letterhead, September 28, 2001, to Doobo Co. (S) PTE Ltd. of Singapore. This invoice states that a total of 2,499,765 metric tons of PBSY cottonseed oil, at about $4xx per metric ton was brought from the port of Houston, Texas to Pyongtaek, Korea on the Golden Tomo. The total value of the merchandise is about $1,000,000. The Bill of Lading, dated September 28, 2001, for the Golden Tomo V.6, states that 1,499.923 MT PBSY Cottonseed oil (food grade) was transported from the Port of Houston, Texas to Pyongtaek, Korea. The second Certificate of Analysis on Thionville Laboratories, Inc. letterhead, dated September 28, 2001, represents 3,306,730 pounds or 1,499.923 metric tons PBSY Cottonseed oil on board the Golden Tomo. The sample taken was in accordance with AOCS Official Method C 1-47. It found: The oil is reasonably free from visible foreign material. The oil is clear at temperatures sufficiently high to melt the stearine. Flavor and Odor Sweet Bleached Color 16 Yellow; 1.6 Red Free Fatty Acids, as Oleic 0.09% Moisture and Volatile Matter 0.10% This oil is in accordance with rule 162 and E-6 of the NCPA current rules. Also included in the file is a consolidated activity register for the ADM processing division. It is dated October 31, 2001, and includes payment for four shipments from the Golden Tomst on September 27, 2001 and September 28, 2001. Finally, the file contains the U.S. Customs Service at the Port of New Orleans’s April 25, 2003, liquidation notice to Archer Daniels Midland Co. A similar notice was sent for each of the four claims. Drawback was denied because the merchandise was not found to be commercially interchangeable and the “internal control policies and procedures were not adequate in the area of maintaining supporting documentation for its Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States Chapter 98 entries.” ISSUES: Whether the imported and exported semi- refined cottonseed oil are commercially interchangeable for the purposes of 19 U.S.C. 1313(j)(2)? Whether the port may deny the drawback claims based on a suspicion that the oil was not exported? LAW & ANALYSIS: Initially, we note that the protest was timely filed under the statutory and regulatory provisions for protests (see 19 U.S.C. §1514 and 19 CFR Part 174). The drawback entries were liquidated on April 25, 2003, and the protest was filed on July 23, 2003. We note that the refusal to pay a claim for drawback is a protestable issue (see 19 U.S.C. §1514(a)(6)). Issue 1: Under 19 U.S.C. §1313(j)(2), as amended, drawback may be granted if there is, with respect to imported duty paid merchandise, any other merchandise that is commercially interchangeable with the imported merchandise and if the following requirements are met. The other merchandise must be exported or destroyed within three years from the date of importation of the imported merchandise. Before the exportation or destruction, the other merchandise may not have been used in the United States and must have been in the possession of the drawback claimant. The party claiming drawback must either be the importer of the imported merchandise or have received from the person who imported and paid any duty due on the imported merchandise a certificate of delivery transferring to that party, the imported merchandise, commercially interchangeable merchandise, or any combination thereof. The issue before us in this case is commercial interchangeability of the merchandise. Compliance with the Customs Regulations on drawback is mandatory and a condition of payment of drawback (United States v. Hardesty Co., Inc., 36 CCPA 47, C.A.D. 396 (1949); Lansing Co., Inc. v. United States, 77 Cust. Ct. 92, C.D. 4675; see also, Guess? Inc. v. United States, 944 F.2d 855, 858 (1991) "We are dealing [in discussing drawback] with an exemption from duty, a statutory privilege due only when the enumerated conditions are met" (emphasis added)). Before its amendment by Public Law 103 182, the standard for substitution was fungibility. House Report 103 361, 103d Cong., 1st Sess., 131 (1993) contains language explaining the change from fungibility to commercial interchangeability. According to the House Ways and Means Committee Report, the standard was intended to be made less restrictive, i.e., "the Committee intends to permit substitution of merchandise when it is ‘commercially interchangeable,’ rather than when it is ‘commercially identical’” (the reference to "commercially identical" derives from the definition of fungible merchandise in the Customs Regulations, prior to their amendment in 1998 (19 C.F.R. 191.2(l)). The report, at page 131, also states: The Committee further intends that in determining whether two articles were commercially interchangeable, the criteria to be considered would include, but not be limited to: Governmental and recognized industry standards, part numbers, tariff classification, and relative values. The Senate Report for the NAFTA Act (S. Rep. 103 189, 103d Cong., 1st Sess., 81 85 (1993)) contains similar language and states that the same criteria should be considered by Customs in determining commercial interchangeability. The amended Customs Regulations, 19 CFR 191.32(c), provide that in determining commercial interchangeability: ...Customs shall evaluate the critical properties of the substituted merchandise and in that evaluation factors to be considered include, but are not limited to, Governmental and recognized industrial standards, part numbers, tariff classification and value. The best evidence whether those criteria are used in a particular transaction are the claimant’s transaction documents. Underlying purchase and sales contracts, purchase invoices, purchase orders, and inventory records show whether a claimant has followed a particular recognized industry standard, or a governmental standard, or any combination of the two, and whether a claimant uses part numbers to buy, sell, and inventory the merchandise in issue. The purchase and s