Base
0841641989-09-20Headquarters

Internal Advice 11/89 concerning the classification of a nonwoven disposable coverall made of Tyvek spun-bonded olefin

U.S. Customs and Border Protection · CROSS Database

Summary

Internal Advice 11/89 concerning the classification of a nonwoven disposable coverall made of Tyvek spun-bonded olefin

Ruling Text

HQ 084164 September 20, 1989 CLA-2 CO:R:C:G 084164 LS CATEGORY: Classification TARIFF NO.: 384.9305 District Director of Customs Lincoln Juarez Bridge P.O. Box 3130 Laredo, Texas 78041-3130 RE: Internal Advice 11/89 concerning the classification of a nonwoven disposable coverall made of Tyvek spun-bonded olefin Dear Sir: This request for internal advice was initiated by a letter, dated September 28, 1988, from Siegel, Mandell & Davidson, P.C., on behalf of Texel Industries, Inc. At issue is entry no. 027-1803097-2, dated June 7, 1988. A sample was submitted for examination. FACTS: The merchandise at issue is a nonwoven disposable protective coverall (Style 2120-1Z) manufactured of Type 1422A (nonporous) Tyvek. Durafab, a division of Texel Industries, Inc., manufactures and imports the garment from Mexico. Tyvek is a patented material which is manufactured and sold exclusively by E.I. DuPont De Nemours & Company, Inc. (hereafter Dupont). Tyvek is a spunbonded olefin which is made of high density polyethylene fibers which are formed into a sheet by first extruding continuous strands of very fine, interconnected fibers and then bonding them together with heat and pressure to form a virtually impermeable fabric. Type 14 Tyvek is a "soft structure" product which is nonpermeable, - 2 - and may be coated or noncoated. Type 1422A Tyvek is a noncoated Type 14 material which weighs approximately 1.10 to 1.20 ounces per yard. Dupont also manufactures a Type 16 Tyvek, which is also "soft structure," but is pin perforated with 10 to 15 mil holes. Type 16 Tyvek allows for the passage of more water vapor and air than Type 14 Tyvek. The subject garment, Style 2120-1Z, is a one-piece coverall with a zippered front, long sleeves, and a collar. The submitted sample is size extra large. Style 2120-1Z is also made in sizes small, medium, and large. The sample is submitted in a plastic bag which contains pictures of a coverall, labcoat, and two piece garment. The following statement is included on the bag: "Quality designed produced and inspected . . . all purpose protective clothing and accessories." The importer, through its attorney, has informed us that the plastic bags are used solely for shipping samples to potential customers and that these packaged samples include different styles of coveralls, whether or not they are made of Tyvek. The subject coveralls are shipped in cartons in bulk to customers. Inside the collar of Style 2120-1Z is a sewn label which reads, in part: "The dimensions of this garment meets or exceeds the requirements of ANSI/ISEA 101-1985" [sic]. Durafab states that this coverall is cut larger than standard cloth overalls. The "ANSI/ISEA 101-1985" is a standard accepted and published by the American National Standards Institute which is intended to provide minimum requirements for finished garment dimensions, labeling, and packaging of men's limited use and disposable protective coveralls. Garments which meet the requirements of the standard provide the user with an assurance of the minimum level of fit. Texel Industries, Inc., through its attorney, contends in the internal advice request that Style 2120-1Z is classifiable in item 384.9305, TSUSA, which provides for "nonwoven disposable apparel designed for use in hospitals, clinics, laboratories, or contaminated areas," and not in item 384.9310, TSUSA, which provides for "coveralls, overalls, jumpsuits, and similar apparel," textile category 659. The importer claims that classification in item 384.9305, TSUSA, is proper because the garment is specially designed for, and primarily used, in contaminated areas. Among the most common contaminants which this garment protects against are asbestos, radioactive dust, pesticides, and viral agents which have plagued the poultry industry, such as the Avian flu. Texel Industries, Inc. states that the subject merchandise is the predominant garment used for contaminant protection in the asbestos work field. The garment is also used to protect the environment from contamination by individuals, such as in clean room applications and laboratories. When garments made of Type - 3 - 1422A Tyvek are used in clean room environments, they are generally for onetime use, as compared with garments made of a heavy weight Tyvek (Type 1445), which can be recleaned and reused a number of times before discarding. We are informed that although the subject garment may be used in other than contaminated areas, such as the food handling industry, it is primarily used to protect workers against toxic chemicals. The importer claims that the classification of the instant garment is not governed by Headquarters Ruling Letter (HRL) 080056, dated August 27, 1987, which determined that a nonwoven disposable coverall made of 100 percent spun-bonded polypropylene was classifiable in item 384.9310, TSUSA, rather than item 384.9305, TSUSA. The garment in that ruling was not found to be designed for use in hospitals because it had no features which adapted it for that purpose. The ruling concluded that the garment appeared to be "multi-purpose" because similar garments were being imported with different labels indicating non-medical uses such as car maintenance. The garment appeared to serve the overall purpose of preventing one's clothing worn underneath from getting dirty. HRL 080056 also compared the garment to another coverall sold by the same importer. The other coverall was described as "identical," except that it was constructed of a different nonwoven fabric, and was used for dirty industrial jobs. The comparison garment was made of spun bonded olefin which was described as "Tyvek." HRL 080056 concluded that the garment at issue could not be said to be designed for use in hospitals because both it and the Tyvek garment had exactly the same design and were claimed to be used for different functions. Texel Industries, Inc. contends that HRL 080056 is in error in determining that Tyvek coveralls are multi-purpose garments. The importer assumes that Headquarters was not apprised of, and therefore, failed to consider the special properties of both Tyvek and the protective garments made from that material. The importer also argues that HRL 080056 is in error with respect to its classification of the coverall made of 100 percent spun-bonded polypropylene. Texel Industries, Inc. reasons that the finding that the coverall could be used in hospitals, clinics, laboratories or contaminated areas indicates that it is suitable for such uses and, therefore, must have been specially designed with particular features which adapt it for those purposes. The importer's position is that a highly protective special purpose fabric used in manufacturing the subject protective garment is one of the most important features of such a garment, and is evidence that the garment is designed for use in contaminated areas. - 4 - ISSUE: Whether the subject coverall is classifiable in item 384.9305, TSUSA, as "nonwoven disposable apparel designed for use in hospitals, clinics, laboratories, or contaminated areas," or in item 384.9310, TSUSA, as "coveralls, overalls, jumpsuits, and similar apparel," textile category 659? LAW AND ANALYSIS: Item 384.93, TSUSA, provides for "Other women's, girls', or infants' wearing apparel, not ornamented: of man-made fibers: Not Knit: Other: Other: Nonwoven disposable apparel designed for use in hospitals, clinics, laboratories, or contaminated areas [statistical breakout 384.9305]; coveralls, overalls, jumpsuits and similar apparel [statistical breakout 384.9310]; . . . ." Since the subject garment is classifiable in item 384.93, TSUSA, we must further determine whether it meets the criteria for "nonwoven disposable apparel designed for use in hospitals, clinics, laboratories or contaminated areas," in item 384.9305, TSUSA, which does not provide for a textile category number. If it is not classifiable in that provision, then it would be classifiable in item 384.9310, TSUSA, textile category number 659. It is established that the subject garment is nonwoven disposable apparel. The issue that must be decided is whether it is "designed for use in hospitals, clinics, laboratories, or contaminated areas." The term "use in contaminated areas" is not defined in the TSUSA, and there is no legislative history covering item 384.9305, TSUSA, since this statistical breakout was administratively created by the "484(e) Committee," which consists of representatives of the Department of the Treasury, the Department of Commerce, and the International Trade Commission and was established pursuant to section 484, Tariff Act of 1930. There are also no prior rulings which specifically interpret this term. The term appears to cover the type of contamination area uses of the subject garment, i.e., radioactive, pesticide, asbestos, and chemical contamination, as well as environments where there is bacterial or viral contamination, such as poultry farms affected by outbreaks of the Avian flu virus. There have been several court decisions interpreting the term "designed for use" or similar language under the TSUSA, and the Tariff Acts of 1913 and 1930. In United States v. Faber, 7 Ct. Cust. Appls. 406, T.D. 36980 (1917), the phrase "designed to be worn on apparel or carried on or about or attached to the person," found in paragraph 356 of the Tariff Act of 1913, was interpreted to include only articles that were - 5 - "peculiarly and specially fitted for being carried on or about the person and devoted to such use." In Plus Computing Machines, Inc. v. United States, 44 CCPA 160, C.A.D. 655 (1957), the court held that the phrase found in paragraph 372 of the Tariff Act of 1930, i.e., "specially constructed for" a particular purpose, when used in reference to an article, means that the article includes particular features which adapt it for that purpose. The court noted that the purpose need not be the sole or principal one served by the article. The court held that a machine with structural features which served the specific purpose of enabling it to multiply and divide and which incorporated those features solely for that purpose was "specially constructed for multiplying and dividing." This machine was clearly distinct from one designed for no purpose other than addition or subtraction. In American Astral Corp. v. United States, 62 Cust. Ct. 563, C.D. 3827 (1969), the Customs Court held that certain gloves which were shown to be specially designed for use in the game of tennis were properly classifiable as lawn tennis equipment. Among the factors considered by the court were: (1) the unique features incorporated in the gloves, such as a terry cloth backing and a lambskin palm designed to absorb moisture, which were not found in other types of sporting gloves or dress gloves; (2) the nature of the importer's business; (3) how the gloves were advertised in the trade; (4) the types of stores where the gloves were sold; and (5) how the gloves were packaged. The court noted that the fact that the gloves had other possible uses did not preclude their classification as sporting equipment. In another sports glove case, Sports Industries, Inc. v. United States, 65 Cust. Ct. 470, 473, C.D. 4125 (1970), the court held that "whether an article is 'specially designed' or 'specially constructed' for a particular purpose may be determined by an examination of the article itself, its capabilities, as well as its actual use or uses." The court found that gloves which were made of a non-porous rubber material were designed for use in the sport of skin diving or scuba diving to protect the hands and to keep them warm, and were therefore classifiable as gloves specially designed for use in sports rather than as other rubber gloves. The record showed that those gloves were used primarily, if not exclusively, in the sport of underwater swimming, and were not suitable for any other practical use. In Porter v. United States, 76 Cust. Ct. 97, C.D. 4641 (1976), the court found that certain gloves were specially designed for use in the sport of motocross racing, even though they were not used exclusively for that sport. One of the expert witnesses testified that - 6 - although the motocross gloves would increase protection in ordinary motorcycle riding, the street rider would find the gloves to be uncomfortable because they offered no protection from the cold. In addition, another expert testified that the gloves at issue were of the type that would comply with the American Motorcycle Association Motocross Competition Rule Book's requirements for certain protective clothing and equipment, which included gloves. In deciding whether an article is classifiable in a "designed for use" provision, the controlling factor, as reflected in the above court decisions and in HRL 080056 and 081415, is whether the article has particular features which adapt it for the stated purpose. In HRL 081415, dated May 2, 1989, Customs determined that certain bouffant-style hats were not classifiable as nonwoven disposable headgear designed for use in hospitals, clinics, laboratories, or contaminated areas because they had no special design features which distinguished them from the same style caps used in other environments. The two main characteristics of the subject coverall which the importer claims are special design features are the use of Tyvek material, which has superior barrier and chemical resistance properties, and the garment's unique fuller-body size and shape. The latter feature is said to distinguish the coveralls from general purpose cloth coveralls. Texel Industries, Inc. claims that the instant garment is specially designed to fit loosely over general purpose cloth coveralls, and meets the American National Standard size and labeling requirements for men's limited use and disposable protective coveralls. The evidence presented by the importer indicates that the Type 14 Tyvek used to make the subject coverall has unique properties which make it designed for use in contaminated areas. Dupont states that Tyvek was developed in 1967 specifically as a protective material for hazards like asbestos. Texel Industries, Inc. has submitted several independent laboratory studies which were conducted for the purpose of determining the specific suitability of Tyvek, and garments manufactured therefrom, for use in protecting workers against specific hazards and contaminants. The laboratory tests analyzed the effectiveness of Tyvek in protecting against penetration by asbestos fibers, radioactive particulates, fiberglass, and carbaryl pesticide dust. One of the unique properties of Type 14 Tyvek which makes it designed for use in contaminated areas is its impermeability. The superior barrier properties of Tyvek are attributed to the manufacturing process of bonding the fibers with heat and pressure. With respect to its effectiveness as a - 7 - barrier against asbestos, studies conducted for Dupont have shown that Type 14 Tyvek blocks the penetration of over 99 percent of asbestos fibers that are less than 0.5 microns in diameter. Tyvek is compared with 1.5 oz. "air permeable" SB/Meltblown polypropylene fabric which blocks the penetration of only 73.9 percent of such fibers. According to Dupont and the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health, these small fibers make up a large percentage of airborne asbestos and are the most active in producing cancerous tumors. With respect to carbaryl pesticide dust, Tyvek 1422A is greater than 97 percent effective as a barrier after four hours of pressurized exposure to particles as small as .6 microns. Another property of Tyvek which makes it suitable for use in contaminated areas is its chemical resistance. This characteristic is attributable to the chemical properties of the polyethylene fibers. Dupont states that Tyvek is resistant to most organic and inorganic chemicals and inert to most acids, bases, and salts. It provides splash protection because